Advocacy
Josh Jones talked about his time with the Kansas City Symphony and the longstanding racism and barriers he says Black musicians face within the American orchestral community.
In July 2020, I left a tenured principal position to join the Kansas City Symphony, a decision that required significant professional risk and personal sacrifice. On January 10, 2023, I was denied tenure for the stated reason of “being disorganized.” I challenged the decision, presenting evidence that directly refuted these allegations and identifying clear contract violations that occurred during and after the tenure process. The Kansas City Symphony chose to uphold a decision after being apprised of the misinformation rather than conduct a fair and transparent review. Faced with a secret internal process and no avenue for accountability, I made the decision to speak publicly about my situation.
Following a public protest supported by individuals and advocacy organizations such as Sphinx and the Black Orchestral Network, and national media outlets, including The Washington Post, reported on the situation. While the Kansas City Symphony did not reverse or properly investigate the tenure decision, the public scrutiny sparked broader industry conversations about transparency, accountability, and racial equity in tenure and audition processes.
In 2024, the Black Orchestral Network, in collaboration with the American Federation of Musicians, developed model tenure guidelines for orchestras to adopt within their Collective Bargaining Agreements. A number of orchestras have since incorporated these guidelines or established task forces to evaluate their audition and tenure systems for fairness and equity. The Kansas City Symphony has not.
As stated by the Black Orchestral Network,
"Black musicians disproportionately have trouble securing orchestral tenure. We know this to be true from both lived experiences and from the historical record. There’s a long history going back at least as far as Elayne Jones, the barrier-breaking African American timpanist with the San Francisco Symphony. When our playing is not an issue, tenure committees find other, pretextual ways to criticize the way we do our jobs. Much too often, “leadership” or “management” or similar factors become the excuse instead.”
It is also deeply concerning to learn of additional, undisclosed allegations of racial discrimination at the Kansas City Symphony since my departure, reinforcing that my experience was not an isolated issue, but part of a larger systemic problem there in particular. No musician or employee should face procedural ambiguity, unchecked bias, conflicts of interest, or retaliation.


"The Black Orchestral Network and members of the wider KC music community are protesting the decision, and questioning the process that brought about this result."
For these reasons, I continue to speak openly and unapologetically about what happened to me. I have presented on principal percussion duties and navigating the tenure process at the Percussive Arts Society International Convention and have spoken on panels at the National Youth Orchestra summer program, the Black Orchestral Network Annual Summit, and other forums. I am actively seeking additional platforms and collaborations to share my full experience and documentation not for personal vindication, but to present a clear case demonstrating why structural change is necessary. Even now, I am contacted for advice by musicians dealing with similar issues in their respective ensembles. Orchestras must adopt transparent and enforceable tenure guidelines that protect musicians from bias, retaliation and contractual abuse. My goal is to ensure that transparency and equity are the industry standard and that what has happened to me and so many others never happens again.
In the Press
This Black Musician Says He Was Unjustly Fired From His Orchestra Job. Now He’s Calling Out A System Of Inequality
Josh Jones talked about his time with the Kansas City Symphony and the longstanding racism and barriers he says Black musicians face within the American orchestral community.
Josh Jones thought the Kansas City Symphony dismissed him unjustly — and took his complaints public. Supporters say he’s exposing an antiquated system that thwarts promising young talent.
Josh Jones, the Kansas City Symphony’s first Black tenure-track musician, speaks out about his experiences working at the organization
In September 2020, percussionist Josh Jones became the first Black tenure-track musician in the Kansas City Symphony’s history, founded in 1982. Jones was denied tenure earlier this spring, sparking outrage not only among Kansas City’s local music scene but the orchestral community on a national level. Jones sat down with The Pitch to speak about his encounters working with the organization.
Industry Leaders
Orchestras with updated audition and tenure guidelines:
Grant Park Orchestra
New York PhilharmonicOregon SymphonyPittsburgh SymphonySt. Louis SymphonyToledo SymphonyToronto Symphony

.webp)